Tucson Shower Designs: Shower Enclosures vs. Shower Curtains For Your Bathroom Remodel

Last Updated on July 25, 2023 by support

Dive Into The World Of Shower Designs

Have you ever found yourself standing in your bathroom, looking at your shower, and wondering how you could refine its charm? Or maybe you’re contemplating a complete bathroom remodel, and you’re torn between shower enclosures and shower curtains?

We’re about to delve into the shower enclosures vs. shower curtains debate, taking a look at the pros and cons of each.

By the time you complete this post, you’ll be ready to decide which best fits your bathroom needs.

Shower Enclosures vs. Shower Curtains

Corner shower enclosure
Shower with patterned curtain

When planning your bathroom remodel, the question of whether to choose a shower door or a shower curtain is often one of the first to arise.

They both serve the same primary function: keeping water off the floor. But the differences are significant, influencing the space, cost, and overall appearance of your bathroom.


  • Provides privacy while taking a shower.
  • Plays a role in controlling water spray.
  • Can enhance the aesthetic appeal of a bathroom.
  • Requires some level of maintenance.
  • Comes in a variety of styles and designs.


  • Shower doors are typically more expensive than shower curtains.
  • Shower doors are more durable and have a modern appearance, while shower curtains offer a softer aesthetic.
  • Shower curtains are easily interchangeable, allowing for a quick decor change.
  • Shower doors require installation, while shower curtains can usually be easily installed by the homeowner.
  • Shower doors offer a more effective barrier against cold drafts and water splashes.

Shower Enclosure Pros And Cons

Light blue shower enclosure


Aesthetically Pleasing

Shower doors, particularly glass shower doors, introduce a sleek, modern appearance to any bathroom.

With their appealing and clean lines, they are aesthetically pleasing. A sparkling shower door can make your bathroom look bigger and brighter, thus adding a touch of luxury.

Customizable Style And Design Options

When it comes to shower doors, there are lots of options.

You can select from various glass types, frames, and patterns. The customizable style and design options allow you to create an attractive shower door that fits your existing bathroom decor perfectly.

There are many other shower ideas that can also accentuate your bathroom decor, too.

Different Entrance Types

Shower doors offer various entrance options.

This flexibility is a bonus, especially if you have a uniquely shaped space. Whether it’s a sliding door for tight spaces or pivoted entrances for larger bathrooms, there’s a shower door to match your needs.

Can Work In Tricky Spaces

A significant advantage of shower doors is their ability to work in tricky spaces.

When standard solutions don’t quite fit your bathroom space, a custom glass shower door can be designed to suit your unique needs.

Can Add Value

An attractive shower door can add value to your home.

When the time comes to sell, a bathroom with a sleek glass shower door is much more appealing than one with a shower curtain.

Cleans Easily

A glass shower door is easy to clean off.

A simple wipe down now and then keeps it looking fresh and free from grime or buildups of mold and mildew.

Reduces Splashing

Shower doors are great at keeping water off the floor.

They create a solid barrier, reducing the risk of splashes or leaks that could lead to water all over the floor.

Prevents Cold Drafts

Shower doors are excellent at preventing cold drafts. No more chilly drafts disturbing your warm, relaxing shower!

Can Break (Rare)

While rare, glass shower doors can break. However, most are made from safety glass that is designed to shatter into small pieces to reduce the risk of injury.


Higher Cost

Despite their many advantages, glass shower doors are more expensive than shower curtains. But for many, the cost is justified by the improved aesthetics and added value.

Don’t Fit Small Bathrooms Well

If your bathroom is compact, a glass door might make it feel cramped. In this situation, a novelty shower curtain might be a better fit.

Need Hinges Or Pivots

Glass shower doors need hinges or pivots to operate. These mechanisms require maintenance to keep the door functioning properly.

Needs Regular Cleaning

To maintain their modern appearance, shower doors need regular cleaning. Otherwise, they might lose their sparkle and appeal.

Shower Curtain Pros And Cons

Baby blue bathroom with floral shower curtain


Lower Cost

One of the major advantages of shower curtains is their reduced cost. They offer an affordable way to provide privacy while adding a splash of color to your bathroom.

Various Colors And Designs (Easily Interchangeable)

Shower curtains come in a wide array of colors and designs, allowing you to show your personality. Plus, they’re easily interchangeable, which means you can update your bathroom decor without a hefty price tag.

Softer Aesthetic

Shower curtains offer a softer aesthetic compared to glass doors. A frilly shower curtain can add a cozy, homey feel to the bathroom, enhancing its comfort.

Works In Any Size Bathroom

Whether your bathroom is large or tiny, a shower curtain can fit well. They are flexible, easy to install, and work in any size bathroom.


Frequent Washing Or Replacement

Shower curtains can trap bacteria, requiring frequent washing or replacement. This could increase your maintenance time and cost.

Water Leakage

Without a solid barrier, shower curtains might not keep all the water off the floor. This could lead to a slippery floor and potential water damage over time.

Can Be Drafty

Despite their charm, shower curtains can be drafty. They lack the insulating quality of glass doors, allowing cold drafts to sneak into your warm shower.

Can Stick To Your Body

Shower curtains have a notorious tendency to stick to your body while you’re showering. This can be an uncomfortable experience and a big downside for many.

PVC vs. Non-PVC

When it comes to shower curtains, material is an important consideration.

PVC, or polyvinyl chloride, is a common material due to its durability and water resistance. However, the production and disposal of PVC can have environmental implications, as it releases toxic chemicals.

Non-PVC alternatives, such as PEVA (polyethylene vinyl acetate) or fabric, are more environmentally friendly. PEVA is a non-chlorinated vinyl and is a great alternative to PVC.

Fabric curtains, while not inherently water-resistant, can be used with a water-resistant liner and provide a more aesthetically pleasing look. They require more maintenance, as they typically need to be washed regularly to prevent mold and mildew.

Each material type offers different advantages and disadvantages.

PVC curtains are easy to clean and highly durable, but their environmental impact may be a deal-breaker for some. Non-PVC curtains require more care but provide a greener alternative with a potentially more appealing aesthetic.

Factors To Consider When Choosing Between A Shower Enclosure And Shower Curtain

Shower with sliding glass door enclosure

The Tucson Factor: Local Trends and Climate Considerations

Living in Tucson, Arizona, you’re no stranger to the warm climate and beautiful, sunny days. Why not incorporate that into your potential shower design ideas?

Glass shower enclosures allow natural light to flood in, making your bathroom a bright, sunlit space.

Moreover, local trends in Tucson show a shift towards minimalistic and modern designs, making shower enclosures a popular choice.

However, the hot climate can also mean a high usage of air conditioning. This can sometimes create a temperature difference in your shower, leading to a potential chilly draft.

A glass shower enclosure would serve well in keeping your shower warm and draft-free.

Considering Your Bathroom Size and Layout

One crucial aspect to think about when choosing between a shower enclosure or shower curtain is your bathroom size and layout.

For smaller bathrooms, you might want to consider shower curtains. They can provide the illusion of a larger space, are flexible, and can be easily pulled back to free up space.

For larger or uniquely shaped spaces, a custom shower enclosure may be the best fit. Glass shower doors can give your room a spacious and luxurious feel.

Durability and Long-Term Maintenance

Long-term durability and maintenance are other factors you should consider.

Shower enclosures, particularly those with glass doors, tend to last longer than shower curtains. If you’re planning to stay in your home for several years, a shower enclosure could be a cost-effective solution in the long run, even with its higher initial cost.

Shower curtains, on the other hand, require frequent replacement. However, their maintenance could be as simple as throwing them in the washing machine, making them a convenient choice for busy homeowners.

Privacy Considerations

Privacy might be a big concern for you, especially if you share the bathroom with others.

Frosted or patterned glass doors can offer a good level of privacy while maintaining aesthetics.

Shower curtains, particularly non-transparent ones, provide maximum privacy.

Which Is Right For Your Bathroom Remodel?

White marble shower with glass enclosure and tub

The right choice between shower doors and curtains largely depends on your personal preference, budget, and space.

Consider the aesthetics, cost, and practicality before making a decision.

Keep in mind whether you opt for a shower curtain or door, both can offer a stylish touch to your bathroom remodel.

Let Frei Remodeling & Construction Transform Your Bathroom Today!

Whether you’re contemplating a full bathroom remodel or just looking to refresh your shower area, the choice between shower doors and curtains is a pivotal one. But deciding between shower doors and curtains is only a part of creating your dream bathroom.

If you’re considering a bathroom remodel in Tuscon, let Frei Remodeling & Construction help you make the right choice. Our experienced team is ready to assist you in exploring the perfect shower designs and delivering a stunning bathroom remodel.

Ready to start your bathroom transformation? Fill out our contact form today or give us a call.

author avatar
Joe Frei

More Posts

Rare Scheduling Opportunity!

Book your project this month to take advantage of priority scheduling!